Key Takeaways
- Buyers who close on December 24 pay the lowest premium of any day of the year, 3.2% above estimated market value, according to ATTOM’s analysis of more than 48 million sales from 2016 through 2025.
- The most expensive closing day is May 27, at a 14.5% premium, so the gap between the best and worst closing dates is 11.3 percentage points.
- July is the cheapest month to close, at a 6.3% premium, followed by November at 7.4% and October at 7.8%, and nine of the ten cheapest closing days fall in July.
- Only two states recorded an actual discount in their best month: Hawaii, at 1.8% below market value in January, and Michigan, at 1.7% below in November.
Most buyers shop for a home by season and negotiate on price. Almost nobody negotiates on the closing date itself, and a new study of a decade of sales says that date carries a measurable price tag.
ATTOM, a property data and real estate analytics provider, released its annual Best Days to Buy a Home analysis on November 12, 2026. The study covers more than 48 million single-family home and condo sales over the past 10 years, from 2016 through 2025.
ATTOM’s method is specific, and it matters for how to use the numbers. For each calendar day, it compared the median sales price of homes that closed on that day with the median automated valuation model (AVM) value for those same homes at the time of sale, and an AVM is a computer estimate of market value.
The Calendar Gap Is 11.3 Points Wide
| Closing day | Premium above estimated market value |
|---|---|
| December 24 (lowest of the year) | 3.2% |
| July 10 | 3.5% |
| July 9 | 4.1% |
| July 3 | 4.3% |
| July 2 | 4.3% |
| July 17 | 4.6% |
| May 27 (highest of the year) | 14.5% |
Put those percentages on a real price and the stakes get clear. On a home with an estimated market value of $400,000, a 3.2% premium is $12,800, while a 14.5% premium is $58,000, a difference of $45,200. Those dollar figures are an author’s calculation applying ATTOM’s percentages to a hypothetical $400,000 value, not figures from the study itself.
Two cautions belong with that math. First, even the cheapest day of the year still closed above estimated market value, so timing trims the premium rather than creating a discount. Second, these are national medians across ten years, not a promise for any one house, street, or year.
The timing question is not academic right now. Contract signings just fell to a record low, with pending home sales down 4.7% in October to an index reading of 63.0, so the buyers who are still in the market are a smaller, more deliberate group than the spring crowd that historically pays the highest premiums.
July Wins the Month, and the Back Half of the Year Wins the Calendar
| Best months to buy, nationally | Premium above estimated market value |
|---|---|
| July | 6.3% |
| November | 7.4% |
| October | 7.8% |
| September | 8.2% |
| December | 8.2% |
July holds both titles at once: it is the cheapest month overall, and nine of the ten cheapest individual closing days fall inside it. The rest of the top five months all sit in the back half of the year, from September through December.
That pattern fits the wider market buyers are negotiating in today. Sellers now outnumber buyers by a record margin, with 70.5% more sellers than buyers in October and only three of the 50 largest metros still favoring sellers, which is the kind of imbalance that gives a flexible buyer room to ask for a closing date as part of the deal.
The state table adds the sharpest insight in the study. Timing alone almost never gets a buyer below market value:
- Hawaii: 1.8% below market value in January, the deepest discount in the study.
- Michigan: 1.7% below market value in November, the only other state with a discount in its best month.
- Connecticut: 0.0% in January, meaning buyers paid right at estimated market value.
- Minnesota: 0.0% in December, also right at estimated value.
- Illinois: a 0.1% premium in November, effectively at value.
ATTOM counted only calendar days with at least 10,000 sales across the decade. Some 362 days met that test, with the four exceptions being January 1, July 4, November 11, and December 25.
How to Use a Closing Date Without Fooling Yourself
The single most useful fact in this study is the one easiest to miss. ATTOM measured closing dates, not offer dates, and a closing normally happens weeks after a buyer signs a contract.
That timing gap is exactly why the lock-in effect matters here. The typical mortgage holder would pay far more to move than to stay, which is why an estimated payment gap of 85.3% keeps so many owners out of the market entirely, and why the sellers who do list late in the year are a self-selected group a patient buyer can work with.
- Work backward from the closing date you want. A buyer aiming to close in the low-premium window around December 24 needs to be under contract well before the holidays, with financing, appraisal, and inspection already moving.
- Put the closing date on the negotiating table. Ask for the date as a term of the offer alongside price and contingencies, especially on a home that has sat through the fall, rather than accepting the default timeline.
- Use your state’s best month, not the national one. A Michigan buyer gains more from a November closing, at 1.7% below estimated value, than from chasing the national December 24 headline.
- Never let the calendar overrule the house. A 3.2% premium on the wrong property is still a bad buy, and a premium is measured against a computer estimate, not against the asking price or an appraisal.
The bottom line is narrow and practical. Buyers cannot control mortgage rates, and they cannot control how many homes are listed, but the closing date is one term of the deal that is genuinely negotiable, and ten years of sales say it is worth real money.
Data source: ATTOM, Best Days to Buy a Home Analysis 2026, released November 12, 2026, covering more than 48 million single-family home and condo sales from 2016 through 2025; figures corroborated by New American Funding, November 18, 2026, and the New York Post, November 12, 2026, reporting the same release.
























