United States Real Estate Investor

United States Real Estate Investor

United States Real Estate Investor

United States Real Estate Investor

United States Real Estate Investor

United States Real Estate Investor

New Homes Are Now $39,600 Cheaper Than Existing Homes, the Widest Gap Since This Index Began

Article Context

This article is published by United States Real Estate Investor®, an educational media platform that helps beginners learn how to achieve financial freedom through real estate investing while keeping advanced investors informed with high-value industry insight.

  • Topic: Beginner-focused real estate investing education
  • Audience: New and aspiring United States investors
  • Purpose: Explain market conditions, risks, and strategies in clear, practical terms
  • Geographic focus: United States housing and investment markets
  • Content type: Educational analysis and investor guidance
  • Update relevance: Reflects conditions and data current as of publication date

This article provides factual explanations, definitions, and strategy insights designed to help readers understand how investing works and how decisions impact long-term financial outcomes.

Last updated: November 19, 2026

PLATFORM DISCLAIMER: To support our mission to provide valuable resources and insights, United States Real Estate Investor® may earn affiliate commissions from links or advertising featured in our content. Images are for informational and entertainment purposes only and may not be fully representative of people or places.

United States Real Estate Investor®
The NAHB/Wells Fargo Cost of Housing Index for Q3 2026 finds the median new home sold for $393,300, which is $39,600 and 9.2% below the $432,900 median existing home, the widest gap since the index began, while a typical family still needed 33% of its income for a new home and 36% for an existing one.
United States Real Estate Investor®
The Trust Is You - Sponsor of Real Estate Investor of the Year 2025 - https://thetrustisyou.com/
United States Real Estate Investor® Books
United States Real Estate Investor®

United States Real Estate Investor® News

Key Takeaways

  • The median new home sold for $393,300 in the third quarter of 2026, which is $39,600 and 9.2% below the $432,900 median existing home, the widest gap with new homes priced below existing homes since the NAHB/Wells Fargo Cost of Housing Index began.
  • A family earning the national median income of $106,800 needed 33% of its income for a median-priced new home, down from 34% in the second quarter, while an existing home took 36%.
  • Low-income families, earning half the median, needed 66% of their earnings for a new home but 73% for an existing home, and that existing-home burden rose from 71% in one quarter.
  • Neither option clears the federal cost-burden line: the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development calls a family cost-burdened when it pays more than 30% of its income for housing.

For most of modern housing history, a brand-new home cost more than a used one. That order has flipped, and a quarterly index released today says the flip just reached its widest point on record.

The National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) and Wells Fargo released the third quarter 2026 Cost of Housing Index (CHI) on November 19, 2026. The CHI measures the share of a typical family’s income needed to make a mortgage payment on a median-priced home.

The method is worth knowing before the numbers. The payment assumes a 10% down payment and adds taxes, insurance, and private mortgage insurance, and median family income is published by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).

The Price Gap, in One Table

Third quarter 2026 Median new home Median existing home
Median price $393,300 $432,900
Change from second quarter Down 4.2% from $410,700 Down 0.5% from $434,900
Share of median family income needed 33% 36%
Share of low-income family income needed 66% 73%

The $39,600 gap is an author’s subtraction of the two NAHB medians. In percentage terms, NAHB puts the new home 9.2% below the existing home, and calls it the widest national median price gap with new homes priced below existing homes since the CHI began.

The direction matters as much as the size. New-home affordability improved in the quarter while existing-home affordability held steady for median-income families and got worse for low-income families, whose existing-home burden climbed from 71% to 73%.

That split lines up with what buyers on the ground are already seeing. New-home buyers started with far lower first-year rates than existing-home buyers in the third quarter, which is why builders could open at a 5.01% starting rate while existing-home buyers started at 6.15% in separate Realtor.com data for the same quarter.

NAHB Chairman Bill Owens, a home builder and remodeler from Worthington, Ohio, tied the improvement to builder price cuts. He said:

“New-home affordability improved slightly in the third quarter while existing-home affordability held steady, giving new homes their widest affordability advantage since the CHI began. Builders are working hard to offset rising costs. According to our latest survey, 43% cut prices in October—the highest share since 2020—and 65% offered sales incentives. But policymakers must do more to reduce red tape, address labor shortages and fix supply chains so builders can expand the nation’s housing supply.”

Here is the fresh insight most coverage will skip. Even the winning option in this report fails the federal affordability test, and it fails it for the median family, not just for low-income buyers.

HUD defines cost-burdened families as those “who pay more than 30% of their income for housing,” and a severe cost burden as paying more than 50%. Against that line, a new home at 33% and an existing home at 36% both leave a typical family cost-burdened, and both leave a low-income family, at 66% and 73%, severely cost-burdened.

Rates worked against buyers even as new-home prices fell. The average 30-year mortgage rate in the index rose from 6.51% in the second quarter to 6.79% in the third quarter, which is why a price drop of more than $17,000 on the median new home only moved its income share down one point, from 34% to 33%.

NAHB Chief Economist Robert Dietz made the same point from the builder side. He said:

“Builders are working with buyers to make new homes more affordable and appealing in a tough market, yet the latest CHI data show housing costs still overburden families. As builders contend with rising construction costs, tighter lending standards and persistent labor shortages, policymakers should remove regulatory obstacles, enact permitting reform and create a stronger business environment that enables builders to produce more attainable, affordable homes.”

The strain Dietz describes is showing up in builder sentiment itself. Confidence fell to its lowest reading since 2012 this month, which is why 46% of builders are now cutting prices and 68% are offering incentives in the separate November survey, a backdrop that helps explain why new-home prices fell 4.2% in one quarter while existing prices barely moved.

Where the Burden Is Heaviest, and Where It Is Lightest

The CHI also breaks existing-home costs down for 175 metropolitan areas. Nationally, the typical family is severely cost-burdened in 8 of those markets, cost-burdened in 87 others, and at 30% of earnings or lower in 80 markets.

Most severely cost-burdened markets, existing homes Share of typical family income
San Jose-Sunnyvale-Santa Clara, Calif. 79%
Urban Honolulu, Hawaii 73%
San Diego-Chula Vista-Carlsbad, Calif. 70%
San Francisco-Oakland-Fremont, Calif. 66%
Barnstable Town, Mass. 61%

In all five of those markets, low-income families would have to pay between 122% and 157% of their income to cover the mortgage payment, which is another way of saying the median existing home is simply out of reach at half the median income.

  • Decatur, Ill. was the least cost-burdened market, at 17% of a typical family’s income.
  • Elmira, N.Y. followed at 18%, and Peoria, Ill. at 19%.
  • Wichita Falls, Texas, Springfield, Ill., and Davenport-Moline-Rock Island, Iowa-Ill. each came in at 20%.
  • Low-income families in those least-burdened markets would still pay between 34% and 41% of their income.

Supply is the other half of whether this gap can last. Builders started more homes in October even as permits fell to their lowest since May 2020, so the pipeline behind today’s new-home pricing is thinner than the starts headline suggests, and a thinner pipeline is one reason not to assume a $39,600 discount survives into next year.

The Trust Is You - Sponsor of Real Estate Investor of the Year 2025 - https://thetrustisyou.com/

How a Beginner Investor or Buyer Can Use This

  1. Price new construction first in your market, not last. The national order has flipped, so a resale-only search can miss the cheaper median option. Pull the CHI metro table for your area, since the index covers existing-home costs in 175 metros.
  2. Run the full payment, not the sticker price. The CHI uses 10% down and adds taxes, insurance, and private mortgage insurance. Rebuild any deal you are weighing the same way, then divide by income to see whether it clears the 30% cost-burden line.
  3. Ask about the cut and the incentive separately. A builder price cut lowers the loan amount and the tax base, while an incentive such as a rate buydown lowers the payment. Owens put the October shares at 43% cutting prices and 65% offering incentives, so both questions are normal to ask.
  4. Do not import the national gap into a coastal metro. At 79% of income in San Jose and 73% in Urban Honolulu, the median existing home is not a starter purchase at any realistic down payment, while Decatur at 17% leaves real room for a first rental or house hack.
  5. Treat the gap as a window, not a law. It was created by a 4.2% one-quarter drop in new-home prices against a 0.5% drop for existing homes, with rates rising from 6.51% to 6.79% over the same period. One quarter of different price moves can narrow it again.

The bottom line is narrow and useful. New homes are now the cheaper median buy in America by the widest margin this index has recorded, but cheaper has not yet meant affordable, and the buyers who benefit most will be the ones who check their own metro’s numbers instead of trading on the national headline.

Data source: National Association of Home Builders and Wells Fargo, Cost of Housing Index for the third quarter of 2026, released November 19, 2026; figures corroborated by Floor Focus and HBS Dealer, November 19, 2026, reporting the same release.

United States Real Estate Investor®

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Thank you for visiting United States Real Estate Investor.

United States Real Estate Investor®

Information Disclaimer

The information, opinions, and insights presented on United States Real Estate Investor are intended to educate and inform our readers about the dynamic world of real estate investing in the United States.

While we strive to provide accurate, up-to-date, and reliable information, we encourage readers to consult with professional real estate advisors, financial experts, or legal counsel before making any investment decisions.

Our team of expert writers, researchers, and contributors work diligently to gather information from credible sources. However, the real estate market is subject to fluctuations, changes, and unforeseen events.

United States Real Estate Investor cannot guarantee the completeness or accuracy of the information presented, nor can we be held responsible for any actions taken based on the content found on our website.

We may include links to third-party websites, products, or services.

These links are provided for convenience and do not constitute an endorsement or approval by United States Real Estate Investor.

We are not responsible for the content, privacy policies, or practices of any third-party sites.

Opinions expressed by contributors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of United States Real Estate Investor.

We welcome diverse perspectives and encourage healthy debate and discussion.

By accessing and using the content on United States Real Estate Investor, you agree to this disclaimer and acknowledge that the information provided is for informational and educational purposes only.

If you have any questions, concerns, or feedback, please feel free to visit our contact page.

United States Real Estate Investor.

United States Real Estate Investor®
Picture of United States Real Estate Investor®
United States Real Estate Investor®

Helping you learn how to achieve financial freedom through real estate investing.

Don't miss out on the value

Join our thousands of subscribers

Subscribe to our newsletter to learn how to attract clients, close deals faster, and a lot more!

United States Real Estate Investor logo
United States Real Estate Investor®
United States Real Estate Investor®

This is the easiest way to know the industry.
The Ultimate Real Estate Investing Glossary

United States Real Estate Investor®

More content

United States Real Estate Investor®

notice!

Web & Social yearly Package

Please, have ad set files ready before purchase.

Please, be aware that after your purchase on the Stripe payment portal, keep your browser open; You will be automatically redirected to the ad set submission page.

notice!

Web & Social Monthly Package

Please, have ad set files ready before purchase.

Please, be aware that after your purchase on the Stripe payment portal, keep your browser open; You will be automatically redirected to the ad set submission page.