Key Takeaways
- Single-family rent prices rose 2.3% year over year in September 2026, the strongest annual increase since June 2025 and the seventh straight month of strengthening growth, according to Cotality.
- The recovery is lopsided by price tier. High-end single-family rentals rose 3.0%, while low-end rentals rose just 1.0%.
- Rent declines are disappearing. Only two of the 50 metros Cotality tracks posted an annual decline in September, down sharply from 13 in February.
- Chicago led the featured markets at 5.0% growth, while Houston was slowest at 0.9%. National rents still sit 39.2% above February 2020 levels.
Single-family landlords are quietly getting their pricing power back. It is just arriving unevenly, by city and by rent level.
That is the picture from the Cotality Single-Family Rent Index for September 2026, released November 19, 2026. The index tracks rent changes on single-family homes listed in the Multiple Listing Service, using a repeat-pairing method.
The fresh insight for beginner investors is the split inside the headline. A 2.3% national gain sounds modest, but the top of the market is rising three times as fast as the bottom, and that gap says a lot about where a new landlord can actually push rent.
Seven Straight Months of Stronger Growth, Still Below the Old Normal
September marked the seventh consecutive month that single-family rent growth strengthened. The 2.3% annual gain is the strongest reading since June 2025.
Context matters here. Before 2020, single-family rent growth ran in a 2% to 4% range for nearly a decade and averaged 3.4%, so today’s pace still sits below historical norms.
“These trends point to a recovery spreading across more rental markets, not a return to the rapid rent increases of the pandemic era,” said Molly Boesel, senior principal economist at Cotality.
The level, not just the growth rate, is the other half of the story. National single-family rents in September were 39.2% above February 2020 levels.
“For renters, however, today’s increases build on years of accumulated gains: national rents are about 39% above February 2020 levels, meaning even moderate increases add to an already elevated cost burden,” Boesel said.
That tension runs through the wider rental market. Zillow’s October data showed single-family rental demand up 24.3% and renters needing a $14,408 raise to buy instead, which helps explain why tenants keep renewing even as rents climb.
| September 2026 single-family rent reading | Annual change |
|---|---|
| National Single-Family Rent Index | +2.3% |
| Higher-priced rentals | +3.0% |
| Lower-priced rentals | +1.0% |
| Detached rentals | +2.3% |
| Attached rentals | +2.2% |
| Pre-2020 decade average, for comparison | +3.4% |
Detached homes, the classic beginner-investor rental, edged attached rentals 2.3% to 2.2%. The property type barely matters right now; the price tier matters a lot.
Chicago Is Running at 5.0%, Houston at 0.9%, and Almost Nowhere Is Falling
The broadest signal in the report is how few markets are going backward. Only two of the 50 metros Cotality tracks posted an annual rent decline in September, unchanged from August and down sharply from 13 in February.
Among the 10 featured markets, the spread between the strongest and weakest city is more than five to one.
- Chicago: +5.0%, the strongest featured market.
- Philadelphia: +4.4%.
- New York: +3.8%.
- Detroit: +3.6%.
- Los Angeles, Miami and Atlanta: +2.0% each, hovering near the national average.
- Dallas: +1.6%.
- Washington, D.C.: +1.4%.
- Houston: +0.9%, the slowest featured market.
The pattern fits the supply story investors already know. Texas metros, where building ran hottest, sit at the slow end, while older, supply-tight Midwestern and Northeastern markets lead.
Apartment data tells a matching story at a different scale, with apartment rents posting their first October annual gain since 2022. Both sides of the rental market are firming at once, just from different starting points.
Supply ahead points the same way. With apartment starts down to about 76,000 in the third quarter, the lowest since 2012, the wave of new competing units keeps thinning, which supports rent growth into 2027 and 2028.
What a Beginner Landlord Should Do With a Split Market
The tier gap is the actionable part of this report. High-end rents rose 3.0% because higher-income tenants can absorb increases, while low-end rents rose just 1.0% because those tenants cannot.
Run the math on a real lease before assuming the headline applies to you. At the national 2.3% pace, a $2,000 monthly rent supports about a $46 monthly increase at renewal, or about $552 over a year; at the low-end 1.0% pace, the same lease supports only about $20 a month. Those are author’s calculations applying Cotality’s percentages to a hypothetical rent.
- Underwrite your tier, not the national number. If your rental sits in the lower half of its local market, budget closer to 1.0% growth than 2.3%, and let any extra be a bonus.
- Check your metro against the map. A Chicago landlord and a Houston landlord are in different markets right now, 5.0% against 0.9%. Price renewals off your city’s reading, not the headline.
- Spend on the features high-end tenants pay for. The 3.0% tier is where increases stick. Modest upgrades that move a home up a tier can earn more than the same money spent holding a low-tier rent line.
- Protect occupancy first at the low end. With rents already 39.2% above February 2020, a pushed increase that triggers a vacancy costs far more than the increase earns. A reliable tenant renewing at 1.0% beats an empty month.
- Lock the renewal early. Seven straight months of strengthening growth means waiting rarely improves a landlord’s hand. Send renewal terms while your market’s reading is still rising.
Cotality builds the index from MLS rental listings covering attached and detached single-family homes and condominiums, across four price tiers. Its companion Rental Trends data covers more than 11 million rental properties, over 75% of all individually owned rental properties in the United States, across all 50 states and 17,500 ZIP codes.
For beginner investors, the usable lesson is simple. Rent growth is back, it is broadening, and it is strongest exactly where tenants have the most room to pay, so buy and price for the tier you are actually in.
Data source: Cotality, Single-Family Rent Index for September 2026, released November 19, 2026.




















